In Elden Ring, Renna is the NPC that gives you the most important thing Calling bells along with your First Ashes, Lonely Wolf Ashes. But meeting Renna isn’t inevitable, as you have to step back a bit to do so, and the game doesn’t specifically encourage you to do this. The condition to meet Renna is that you must have receive Torrents from Melinathat you go to Elleh Church at night, and you still haven’t made it to the Roundtable.
However, even if you meet these three conditions, you may still have trouble getting Renna to appear. After receiving the Torrent, we headed back to Elleh Church, used the Place of Grace there to pass the time until nightfall, then waited around until it was completely dark. Renna still didn’t show up.
To make Renna appear, we had to get on the map and fast travel to Elleh Church (even though we were at Elleh Cathedral). This caused her to appear right in front of us right after the quick tour was complete. So if you’re having trouble getting Renna to spawn, try a quick trip to Elleh Church at night.
If you’ve made it all the way to the Roundtable Hold, it’s too late to turn around and meet Renna. However, you can still buy the Calling Bells and Lonely Wolf Ashes from the Twin Husks merchant at the Roundtable Hold.
https://www.gamepur.com/guides/renna-the-witch-not-appearing-or-spawning-in-elden-ring-heres-what-you-can-do Renna the witch doesn’t appear or spawn in the Elden Ring? Here’s What You Can Do