Canadaiens can solve drafting problems by replacing Timmins

The Montreal Canadianiens had the worst start in franchise history, losing 13 of the first 17 games of their 112 season. With their general manager (GM) Marc Bergevin final year and may not return, Habs also needs to consider other longtime employees who may have stayed too long. Trevor Timmins has been with the Canadianiens organization for 17 seasons and works as a scout and assistant GM (AGM). He is directly involved in advising them on who to draft, and his results are average at best. Whether Bergevin goes or not, maybe it’s time for Canadians to take a new look when it comes to drafting.

Canmins’ Timmins Helped Draft Some of Habs’ Best Players

Like all of Canada’s coaching staff and management, Timmins is feeling the heat from fans and the media. Timmins has been keeping an eye on him ever since The habits are drafted junior player is considered Logan Mailloux. However, many people forget that in his early days as a scout and head of scouting, Timmins helped the Canadian team recruit some of the best players Habs had over the past decade. . He was responsible for assisting the Canadians in drafting Carey Price (2005), Max Pacioretty, PK Subban (2007) and Brendan Gallagher (2010). Ryan McDonagh (2007) and Mikhail Sergechev (2016) were also drafted by Timmins but never had a career with Canada.

Trevor Timmins Montreal Canada
Trevor Timmins, Assistant General Manager, Montreal Canadaiens (Amy Irvin / Hockey writers)

Timmins, of course, enjoyed this success more than ten seasons ago; Over the past five seasons, he seems to have entered the game well, but only time will tell with some players. Cole Caufield looked like a solid pick, but he fell more in Timmins’ lap than he was picked. Mattias Norlinder and Alexander Romanov should become good options for Canada, but not game changers. Timmins has helped draft some of Canada’s top players over the past 15 seasons, but that doesn’t mean he’s a genius or great at drafting. Price, Pacioretty and Sergechev are brainless guys.

Canmins ‘Timmins has more beauties than hits

Timmins has helped draft some of the better players over the past decade for the Canadaiens, but he also missed quite a few drafts. It’s easy to look back at any year and say they should have drafted one or the other, but in Timmins’ defense, he didn’t get too far to draft a player. Canadaiens also didn’t have high salaries in those 17 years, with an average position of 19 with just three picks out of the top five. An argument could be made that the choices weren’t bad, but the development happened, or that the Canadians were just unlucky. Development was part of the problem, but luckily for most of the last 17 Canadian manuscripts.

Related: Canadians Need Top-Down Cleaning

From 2008 to 2015, for a total of seven seasons, the Canadianiens’ first-round picks were virtually insignificant. Alex Galcheynuk has the most points in the table with 335 points from 587 games, while three of those chosen have never played more than 50 games in the NHL – Louis Leblanc, Noah Juulsen, Nikita Scherbak. The last three picks are playing in the NHL but as bot lanes: Michael McCarron – Nashville Predators, Jarred Tinordi – New York Rangers, and Nathan Beaulieu – Winnipeg Jets. These three played 589 games and scored a total of 15 goals and 111 points – 91 of these were from Beaulieu. When drafting the first round, you should expect to produce more than this. Timmins and company have missed out on some excellent players during this time, such as Chris Kreider, Evgeny Kuznetsov, Morgan Rielly, Shea Theodore and Sebastian Aho, to name a few that were drafted shortly after Canada’s selection.

Canadaiens final round drafting average at best

It’s safe to say that Timmins is average when it comes to picking first-round players, but his last-round stretch is pretty good, depending on how you look at it. He drafted Subban (2007) in the second round and Gallagher (2010) in the fifth round. He also drafted Arturri Lehkonen and Jacob De La Rose (2013), Jake Evans (2014), Victor Mete (2016) all in the second round or later. He also recently drafted Alexander Romanov in 2018 in the second round. Timmins selected some outstanding players for the NHL in the following rounds.

Alexander Romanov Montreal Canada
Alexander Romanov, Montreal Canada, 2018 NHL Draft (Amy Irvin / Hockey writers)

In 17 seasons, Timmins only put out two players in the second round or later who became a star in the NHL. Suburban won the Norris . Cup was the top defensive player in 2013, and Gallagher is a 30-goal scorer in multiple seasons. The rest of the selections are the bottom six players or the bottom couple a penny a dozen in the NHL. He’s drafted quality players that can be serviced, but no one is going to turn the game around or be the difference-maker. Romanov could be the best player picked after the first round since Gallagher – in other words, they have yet to find a diamond in the rough.

Canadaiens’ recent manuscript is better

Are from reset of 2018, the Canadians drafted better first-round picks like Caufield and Kaiden Ghule, who will greatly benefit Canada’s future. If you remove all the external noises associated with Mailloux, he can also evolve into a solid two-way guardian. Habs’ most important problem in previous drafts was choosing the player needed instead of choosing the best player available (BPA): Jesperi Kotkaniemi was the product of drafting for need, and again , that doesn’t suit the team. He never became the player they thought he would be and is now with the Carolina Hurricanes.

Montreal-Canadian Cole Caufield drafts NHL
The Montreal Canadian picks Cole Caufield during the first round of the NHL draft at Rogers Arena in Vancouver, June 21, 2019. (THE CANADIAN PRESS / Jonathan Hayward)

Drafting in later rounds has also improved in recent years. As of 2017, Canadians have drafted Cayden Primeau (2017), Jesse Ylonen, Romanov, Jordan Harris (2018), Jayden Struble, Mattias Norlinders (2019), Jan Mysak, Sean Farrell (2020), Riley Kidney, Joshua Roy and Joe Vrbetic (2021) who are dominating their respective minor leagues – Primeau, Ylonen and Romanov are in the AHL/NHL. Canadians may have taken a turn when it comes to drafting, or perhaps they just stopped drafting when necessary and used BPA. This doesn’t mean that all of these prospects will become NHL stars, but they are doing very well in their respective minor leagues and have a chance to become at least regular NHL players.

Canadians need a new vision

Timmins was in charge of drafting the Canadaiens or at least involved in the process for 17 drafts, and they could only draft one superstar player in Price. Out of their top three picks, Price was the only one to become a star. One could argue that Sergechev is a star, but he is just a top defender in a very good Tampa Bay Lighting team; Even if you count Sergechev, that’s still just two players in 17 seasons to become top NHL players. Even with recent drafts, only Caufield intends to become the top NHL player, which is still not a good enough record to hold the same guy’s place.

It is difficult to determine how the selections of the past five years will play out. Primeau looks like he could be an NHL starter, Ryan Poehling is starting to show signs he’s ready for the NHL and the Canadaiens have a lot of hope still playing underage. The reality, however, is that Timmins hasn’t finished the job yet. He didn’t get the star player the team needed during the draft. Bergevin went on to say that you build through the current, and the Canadaiens maintain the drafting of the first round’s side players. If this trend continues, the Canadian team will spend another 20 seasons as mediocre and with no stars that can help them move forward.

Timmins isn’t the only one to blame here. Canadians are falling behind when it comes to developing players. They flock to the NHL or put prospects in positions they weren’t ready for, causing them to fail. Drafting is also a double-edged sword. To get good players, you have to pull high; To rank high, you have to finish lower in the leaderboard. At this point, Canada needs to replace the Timmins and look at how they draft through different eyes and points of view because, with only one real star after 17 seasons, something can’t be increased. Canadaiens can solve drafting problems by replacing Timmins

Subhankar Mondal

24ssports is an automatic aggregator of the all world’s media. In each content, the hyperlink to the primary source is specified. All trademarks belong to their rightful owners, all materials to their authors. If you are the owner of the content and do not want us to publish your materials, please contact us by email – The content will be deleted within 24 hours.

Related Articles

Back to top button